Article Critique Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words

Critique - Article Exampleectively in the beginning of the study, as it is evident in the following line, The place of this study was to obtain the first-person perspective of the students themselves, a perspectiveabout the academic experience of black students (Davis et al, 2004, p. 420).The literature appears to be pertinent and all-encompassing for the purpose of the study. In a comprehensive way, Davis et al reviewed the literatures that relates the purpose of this study and outlined its salient features. It mainly covers the following areas of the study a. a full statistical view of the universe of discourse of black students in the universities if the countries (American Council on Education, 1988 U.S. Census Bureau, 1993), b. the discrepancy between the enrollments of white students and black students (Echols, 1998 Steele, 1999), c. nature of the prevailing atmosphere for minority student learning (Davis et al, 2004, p. 420) in the educational institutions (Sue et al, 1999 K atz & Hass, 1988), d. attitude of white students to black students (Bjerklie, 2001), e. important aspects of the black college experience (Davis et al, 2004, p. 422). These broad descriptions and findings of the literatures assisted Davis et al to prepare the outline of their investigation.The procedure of the study appears to in fair concordance with the subjective purpose. Davis et al approached the participants of the study with phenomenological interviewing cognitive process. In the first place, they justified their decision -of using phenomenological interview- by focusing on the salient features of the interviewing process as Davis et al asserted that their interview mainly concerns the what of an experience and seeks to capture the specific meanings uniquely characterizing that experience (Davis et al, 2004, p. 423). Their investigation was based on the clues found at bottom the proceeding of the interview, as they said, After the initial question is asked, a phenomenologic al interview